Credit union service organisations have been a fixture in the US for decades. The idea is simple enough. Several credit unions put money, people or both into a separate body that does a job each of them would struggle to do well alone. Lending platforms, card processing, compliance support, collections and back-office administration are the usual candidates.
In the UK the model has been slower to take hold, partly because of how our legislation is drafted and partly, I suspect, because the sector has spent a long time focused on survival. That's starting to change. More credit union boards are asking whether they should be part of something shared, and a handful of UK vehicles now exist, CU Share and Cub Finance among them.
I'll admit to some skin in the game. We were brought in to set up CU Share, so I've seen up close what it takes to get a shared vehicle off the whiteboard and into something that actually runs. I came out of it convinced that this model is right for a lot of UK credit unions, and I'd like to see far more of them doing it. That said, a badly put together CUSO is worse than none at all, so here's what I'd want any board to think about first.
Why the interest now
The economics have been obvious for years. A credit union with a few thousand members carries roughly the same fixed costs for core systems, regulatory reporting, AML tooling and digital channels as one ten times its size. Members, meanwhile, judge you against the app on their phone from a high street bank or a well-funded fintech. Very few credit unions can close that gap on their own balance sheet, and most boards know it.
A shared vehicle spreads those costs and gives the group buying power with suppliers it would never get individually. Done well, it also frees staff to spend time with members instead of reconciling spreadsheets, which is what most of them joined a credit union to do in the first place.
What the rules still expect of you
This is where enthusiasm needs a bit of tempering. Credit unions in Great Britain are dual-regulated, with prudential rules sitting in the Credit Unions Part of the PRA Rulebook and conduct rules with the FCA. Joining a CUSO changes none of that.
A few points boards should keep in front of them:
- Responsibility stays with you. Outsource a function to a shared body and the regulated firm remains accountable for it. Under the Senior Managers and Certification Regime, a named individual at your credit union answers for that arrangement. "The CUSO handles that" won't get you far with a supervisor.
- Investment rules are tight. The PRA's investment rules and the Credit Unions Act 1979 limit what credit unions can do with surplus funds. Before anyone talks about taking an equity stake, get clear advice on what's actually permitted. In many cases a well-drafted service agreement is a cleaner route than ownership.
- Capital and liquidity matter. Any financial commitment to a shared vehicle has to sit comfortably within your capital and liquidity requirements, including in a stress scenario where the CUSO needs more money than planned.
- Exit has to be real. If the shared body fails, or simply stops meeting your needs, you need a credible plan to move the service elsewhere without harming members.
None of this should put anyone off. It just means doing the governance work properly at the start, when it's cheap, rather than scrambling after the first supervisory visit.
Where shared models tend to work
The strongest candidates are functions that are expensive, regulated and largely invisible to members. Compliance monitoring, financial crime controls, regulatory returns, IT procurement and some lending operations all fit. Members rarely care who runs the back office, provided their loan decision arrives quickly and their money is safe.
The weaker candidates are anything that touches the identity of the credit union itself. Common bond, community relationships and the way you treat members in financial difficulty are the reasons you exist. Sharing infrastructure to support those things makes a lot of sense. Handing them over is a different matter, and I'd be wary of any model that blurs the line.
Questions to ask before you join
If your board is weighing up a shared vehicle, I'd want answers to these:
- Who governs it, and how much say does a smaller member have against a larger one?
- What does it cost over five years, including the exit, compared with doing it yourself or buying from a commercial supplier?
- How does it handle data, and who owns it if you leave?
- What happens to pricing once the founding members have their arrangements and new joiners arrive?
- Has anyone tested the arrangement against the PRA's expectations, or is that being left to each credit union to work out?
That last one catches people out more often than you'd think. If the answer is a shrug, keep asking.
A mutual answer to a mutual problem
Collaboration is supposed to be what the credit union movement is all about, so it's always struck me as odd that the sector has so often ended up with each organisation buying, building and struggling on its own. Shared services and collaborative models are one of the more practical ways for credit unions to become the institutions their communities need, offering decent digital service and sensible costs while keeping the people-first approach that sets them apart.
It's an area we spend a lot of our time on, helping credit unions, building societies and banks decide which functions to share, how to structure it so the regulator is comfortable and how to make the numbers stand up. Setting up CU Share was exactly this kind of work, and frankly we'd like to do a lot more of it. That might be a new shared vehicle from scratch, or a group of firms that have talked about collaborating for years and fancy actually getting on with it. Sometimes the right answer is a CUSO. Sometimes it's a straightforward joint procurement, or a partnership with a fintech that has already solved the problem. Either way, it's worth picking on purpose rather than drifting into it.
If you're weighing up a shared model, or thinking about setting one up, happy to talk it through.